Author: admin

  • Halloween Saturday Proved Exactly What a 24-Team Playoff Would Destroy

    If you want to know what college football tastes like when it is still alive, you had to be watching yesterday.
    You had to feel the air go out of the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum—and then roar back to life—as unranked USC dragged No. 2 Ohio State into the deep water and stunned the Buckeyes, 30-18. You had to see the faces in Ames, where Iowa State and No. 24 Oklahoma State traded haymakers until the scoreboard read 51-49, and a two-point margin felt like the difference between heaven and earth. You had to watch No. 1 Miami staring into the abyss in Chapel Hill, needing a fourth-quarter touchdown drive with 2:33 on the clock just to survive a 4-4 North Carolina team, 38-35.
    From Syracuse pulling off a last-second 30-27 stunner over No. 19 SMU with 17 seconds left, to Iowa blanking No. 25 Wisconsin 30-0, to Oregon knocking off No. 20 Northwestern 34-26 in Eugene, six ranked teams walked off the field yesterday with their seasons forever altered. Even No. 4 Indiana needed overtime just to escape Minnesota, 23-16.
    It was chaotic. It was heartbreaking. It was glorious. And if the television executives pushing a 24-team College Football Playoff get their way, a Saturday like yesterday will never feel the same again.
    Think about what USC’s 30-18 upset over Ohio State actually meant last night. The Buckeyes outgained the Trojans by more than 100 yards, held the ball for nearly 40 minutes, and still got punched in the mouth by a team playing like its hair was on fire. With that loss, Ohio State dropped to 6-2. In a real college football season, a second loss on Halloween night is an earthquake. It puts your season on a razor’s edge. It makes every single snap in November a sudden-death referendum on your team’s soul.
    Now, imagine that exact same fourth quarter in Los Angeles under a 24-team playoff.
    In a 24-team format, a 6-2 Ohio State doesn’t walk off the Coliseum turf in stunned silence. They shrug. Why wouldn’t they? Even with a third or fourth loss, a blue-blood roster is virtually guaranteed to finish inside the top 24. Instead of a program-defining upset that shakes the sport to its foundation, USC’s triumph is reduced to an exhibition game that nudges Ohio State from a projected first-round bye down to hosting a home game as the No. 11 seed.
    What about Chapel Hill? When Darian Mensah found Malachi Toney with 2:33 left to save No. 1 Miami’s undefeated season, hurricanes of relief swept through South Florida while heartbreak settled over Kenan Stadium. That tension existed because perfection is fragile, and the margin matters. What about Ames, or Syracuse, or Iowa City? Oklahoma State (now 5-3), SMU (6-2), Northwestern (6-2), Arizona (6-2), and Wisconsin (5-3) all suffered gut-wrenching defeats yesterday. Today, those locker rooms are hurting because losing is supposed to hurt.
    Under a 24-team bloated bracket, three-loss and four-loss power conference teams don’t mourn in November—they just wait for their participation trophy seeding in December. Even worse, the current 24-team blueprint being shopped by network executives would scrap conference championship weekend entirely to clear the calendar for more first-round television inventory. Years of regional pageantry, trophy presentations, and conference races—flushed away so 8-4 teams can get blown out by 20 points before Christmas.
    We don’t love college football because it is a sterile, six-week tournament in December where half the league gets a ticket. We already have the NFL for that. We love college football because on a crisp October night, a four-loss North Carolina team can make the No. 1 team in America sweat bullets. We love it because a stadium full of college kids can storm the field knowing they just ruined a rival’s dream.
    Yesterday gave us everything this sport was built on: desperation, consequence, and unscripted magic. Don’t let the people in boardrooms tell you that taking the stakes out of Saturday is “progress”.
    The December 1 deadline for the 2027–28 playoff format is one month away. If yesterday meant anything to you, help us protect it.