Death Valley, a 9-1 Wake, and Why November Still Matters

Rankings are the Nov. 10 CFP board, unless noted.

Arch Manning found Raleek Brown for a 4-yard touchdown with three seconds left, and No. 6 Texas escaped Death Valley with a 22-21 win over No. 21 LSU. No. 2 Utah stayed unbeaten, 40-39, on a 70-yard strike with 2:35 to play. Indiana beat No. 18 USC 27-13 for its first win ever over the Trojans, to go 9-1. And 9-1 Wake Forest hung 49 on No. 25 AP SMU.

That is what a loss is still allowed to cost. Earn it in November.

The CFP already approved a 24-team playoff for 2027–28. We can still tell the truth about Saturday under 12, and what a doubled field would probably soften.

When a Saturday still has teeth

Death Valley was a pick-fest. Manning and LSU’s Sam Leavitt each threw three interceptions. Texas defensive back Jelani McDonald had three of them, and Lane Kiffin fell to his knees after Leavitt’s third. Then Manning, down 21-16, drove 58 yards and won it at the gun. Texas is 8-2 and still in the 12-team hunt. LSU is 6-4. In a 24-team field, that fourth November loss would likely have been about seeding, not survival.

Utah had to go get it on the road. Devon Dampier hit Creed Whittemore for 70 yards, and the Utes improved to 10-0. Arizona fell to 7-3. In a 24-team bracket, a 7-3 power-conference team would probably already have a seat.

Grant Wilson, in his first start for Indiana, threw for 305 yards and two scores. CBS Sports’ Tom Fornelli said USC is out of playoff contention. A 7-3 USC team, under 24, would likely still be in the hunt. Under 12, that loss closes a door.

Earn it in November

Wake Forest left no doubt, leading 42-0 at halftime and beating SMU 49-7. They entered the week at No. 13, just outside the field. CBS Sports’ RJ Young asked: “If the committee does not have Wake Forest in its top 12 on Tuesday, what are we doing?” In a 24-team world, a 9-1 Wake Forest team would probably already be comfortably inside the bracket.

Clay Travis put the Iron Bowl in plain language: if Alabama lost to Auburn, a 9-3 Tide “would be on playoff ropes and need help.” Alabama is 8-2 after beating Vanderbilt, with Chattanooga and Auburn still to play. In a 24-team world, a 9-3 Alabama would probably stroll in anyway, and the Iron Bowl would be a seeding game.

Fans were not asking for 24. The Athletic survey found 70% of fans oppose a 24-team playoff. We can’t un-approve 2027–28. We can still defend this November. Follow @SaveCollegeFB. Share this. Take action. And keep saying it: earn it in November.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *