No. 1 Fell, Kentucky Crashed, Utah Survived: Why Saturday Proved 12 Is Enough

Make Every Saturday Count: keep the College Football Playoff at 12

Rankings in this post are the CFP Selection Committee’s first rankings, released Nov. 3, 2026. Scores and details link to the game recaps.

We called it in our Week 10 preview: seven games between CFP-ranked teams, and every one with something real at stake. Saturday delivered. The No. 1 team lost. An undefeated team stayed perfect in a rivalry game. Kentucky, coming off its highest CFP ranking ever, lost by 28. And traditional power Ohio State lost its second straight. By midnight the top of the playoff picture looked different than it did at breakfast.

That’s what a 12-team playoff does to November. Here’s what happened, and why it matters for the fight over a 24-team field.

The results

No. 11 Notre Dame 31, No. 1 Miami 24

Notre Dame built a 24-3 lead in the third quarter behind three CJ Carr touchdown passes, then held on as Darien Mensah threw three second-half touchdowns for Miami. The game turned on a single snap. On fourth-and-6 from the Notre Dame 18, Mensah found tight end Eli Lofton in the corner of the end zone, but Lofton couldn’t hold the ball. Miami turned it over on downs with 3:36 left, and a last-second hook-and-ladder fell short. Both teams are now 8-1. Miami had been No. 1 in the CFP rankings for the first time in program history.

No. 2 Georgia 42, No. 10 Ole Miss 7

Georgia led 28-0 at halftime in Oxford and held Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss to 69 first-half passing yards.

No. 3 Utah 28, No. 9 BYU 20

Utah won the Holy War 28-20 and stayed unbeaten. After Miami’s loss, Utah and UCLA are the only teams left with no losses. BYU still has one loss, and that loss came against a ranked rival, so NCAA.com’s analysts even raised whether BYU’s head-to-head win over Notre Dame could keep it in the mix.

No. 13 Tennessee 34, No. 6 Kentucky 6

Tennessee led only 13-6 after three quarters, then scored three fourth-quarter touchdowns. Its defense forced three turnovers, held Kentucky to 0-for-2 on fourth down and kept the Wildcats out of the end zone. Kentucky came in at No. 6, its highest CFP ranking ever, sitting atop the SEC and riding a six-game winning streak. It leaves at 7-2. It was Tennessee’s second straight home win over a top-10 team.

No. 5 Alabama 31, No. 14 LSU 13

Alabama pulled away in Baton Rouge. Keelon Russell went 17-for-24 for 206 yards and three touchdowns. LSU, 6-2 entering the night, now has a third loss.

Also: Oregon 41, Ohio State 28, and Texas 34, Missouri 20

No. 23 Oregon scored 38 unanswered points after falling behind 14-0 to beat No. 12 Ohio State. The Buckeyes, still without starting quarterback Julian Sayin, have now lost two straight. No. 7 Texas beat No. 18 Missouri 34-20, its third straight win and fourth against ranked opponents this season.

Why yesterday mattered

Look at what each of these games did. Notre Dame came in with one loss and a lot to prove. Now it owns a win over the No. 1 team, and its whole season looks different. Kentucky was a feel-good story at No. 6, and one bad night against a rival put that place in doubt. LSU and Ole Miss each took a costly loss. Ohio State is suddenly fighting just to stay relevant.

We are not declaring any team’s playoff hopes over. The committee will sort it out. But for the teams that lost, there is now less room for error, and that’s the point. In a 12-team field, a November loss has to be answered on the field. You win out and hope for help, or you hope the committee values your resume more than the next team’s.

Our view: double the field, and much of that pressure fades. We can’t say exactly how any of yesterday’s teams would be treated under a 24-team format, because no format has been officially announced. But it’s simple arithmetic that the more spots there are, the more room a two- or three-loss contender has. In our view, the pressure that made games like Alabama–LSU and Tennessee–Kentucky feel so big comes from how much a loss can cost. A bigger field would ease that pressure.

The best argument for 24, and our answer

The strongest case for expansion is access. More teams get a shot, and fewer good teams get left out after a close call. Depending on the final format, more fan bases might also get postseason games. That’s a real argument, and plenty of fans who love the sport make it.

Our answer: 12 already gives access. Under the CFP’s official format, the field is the five highest-ranked conference champions plus the next seven highest-ranked teams. Yesterday showed a team can lose a game and still play its way back, which is exactly what Notre Dame is trying to do. What 12 doesn’t do is make the regular season optional. Even Nick Saban, who has floated 16 as a possible compromise, told the New Heights podcast: “There’s not 24 teams in the country that can win the National Championship. So, what is the reason to actually do it?”

For the full side-by-side, read 12 vs. 24 Teams: What CFP Expansion Changes.

Where expansion stands right now

On Nov. 6, the CFP said a formal agreement with ESPN on future media rights “in connection with potential expansion” is “in the final stages of review,” and that “a decision on the agreement will be made following this review.” That’s a review of a TV deal, not an announced 24-team format. Back in September, the CFP said opening those talks “does not represent a decision or commitment to expand.” Reports of how a 24-team bracket might work are still reports. Our explainer What Is the 24-Team College Football Playoff Proposal? keeps track of what’s confirmed and what isn’t.

Your move

Yesterday was a reminder of what we stand to lose: a national title race decided on the field one Saturday at a time. If you felt it, say so. Read the full case against a 24-team playoff, then take action and contact decision-makers before the campaign’s December 1 deadline. Keep it at 12.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *